How would you best care for a victim having an asthma attack who doesn't have an inhaler with them?

For a victim experiencing an asthma attack without an inhaler, the best course of action is to call for emergency medical assistance, such as 911, while also placing the victim in a comfortable position that may help ease their breathing. This response is appropriate because it prioritizes the safety and health of the individual by ensuring that trained medical professionals are on their way to provide further assistance.

In this type of situation, the position in which the victim is placed can allow for better airflow and may help alleviate some discomfort. A sitting position, slightly leaning forward, can often be more effective for easing symptoms than lying down, as this position can help maximize lung capacity and facilitate breathing.

Other options, like encouraging deep breathing or providing water, may not effectively address the immediate needs of someone having a severe asthma attack. Deep breathing could lead to hyperventilation, making the situation worse, while water does not help in managing the airway constriction that occurs during an asthma attack. Using a paper bag is also discouraged, as it can lead to a dangerous increase in carbon dioxide levels in the body. Therefore, the approach of calling for help and aiding the victim into a comfortable position is the most effective and responsible action.